Publication:

Before Suicide Bombings: Ideas and Practices of Self-Murder in the Medieval Arab-Islamic World

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Date

2025

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Princeton, NJ : Princeton University

Research Projects

Organizational Units

Journal Issue

Access Restrictions

Abstract

Suicide is widely condemned in Islamic law and doctrine. As a type of homicide, suicide was both a major sin and a crime, subject to punishment in this world and assured of it in the next. Despite this, there is a lot of evidence that suicides still occurred, even among religious scholars. People in the medieval Arab-Islamic world killed themselves for many reasons: illness, old age, torture, debt, fear of losing face, and more.Despite the vast secondary literature on martyrdom and terrorism in the contemporary Middle East, the premodern history of suicide in the Islamic world is surprisingly understudied. The classic study on the topic was published nearly eighty years ago, and little has been done since. This dissertation provides a comprehensive study of self-killing (qatala nafsahu), both in theory and in practice, in the medieval Arab-Islamic world, c. 600-1400. Using literary sources alongside normative texts, I present the medieval Arabic material on suicide arranged by genre: suicide in Qurʾānic exegesis, suicide in legal texts, suicide in classical Arabic love stories, suicide in historical sources, and the special case of female suicide in historical sources. Throughout the first two chapters I demonstrate that there is no one locus where the Islamic discussion of suicide is centered. These chapters focus on the simple point that Islam is against suicide, despite the fact that Muslim jurists and even the religious scholars do not present their prohibition in a concerted way. The last three chapters show a disconnect between the historiographic and imaginative depictions of suicide on one hand, and the official Islamic attitude towards suicide on the other. I examine hundreds of reports of suicide collected from the Arab-Islamic historical literature and show that in the general run Islamic values are rarely mentioned in the “real” cases of suicide in the historical sources. In fictitious love stories and accounts of female suicide, values incompatible with Islam tend to predominate the narratives. This research demonstrates that outside the strictly religious domain, both literary fantasy and records of real life in Muslim societies either ignore the religious prohibition of suicide or actively subvert it.

Description

Type of resource

Academic dissertations (Ph.D.)

Keywords

Islam, Islamic law, Medieval, Middle East, Suicide

Location

Citation

Collections