Publication: Canada's Science: An Ethnography of Ethics and Expertise in Stem Cell Biology
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Access Restrictions
Abstract
In a series of experiments performed at the Princess Margaret Hospital in Toronto in
1961, Drs. James Till and Ernest McCulloch, a physicist and a hematologist, first
demonstrated the existence of stem cells. The advent of human embryonic stem cell
research in 1998 spurred Canadian scientists and the Canadian government to build on
the country’s research capacity in the field. At the same time, the government put in place
a policy framework which criminalizes certain human embryonic stem cell experiments.
Canadian stem cell science is currently a vibrant research field involving different types
of cells and many different lines of research and it remains a funding priority, despite this
relatively strict policy on human embryonic stem cell research. Drawing on two years of
fieldwork, this dissertation traces the experiences and practices of stem cell scientists,
policy researchers and institutional experts in research review and in commercialization
as they make and remake the meaning and legitimacy of stem cell science. I explore their
morally inflected experiences and modes of analysis as they work to turn stem cell
science to medical benefit. To understand how Canadian stem cell science has maintained
government and public support, I investigate the conditions in which stem cell research is
conducted and shaped in four domains of meaning and practice: that of scientists engaged
in research who are concerned with the scientific validity of their results and the
credibility of their visions, that of the institutional ethics bureaucracy which certifies
research as conforming to Canadian values, that of policy experts trying to steer stem cell
science away from potential controversies and, lastly, that of commercialization experts
working to move research out of the academy to the benefit of patients without activating
public concerns over commercial agendas and profits.