Publication: Rethinking Gun Control: Advocating for Place-Based Preventive Policies as a Primary Solution
Files
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Access Restrictions
Abstract
To deal with gun violence, it is common to hear politicians and advocates promulgate policies designed to reduce the quantity of guns in circulation. These popular policies include background checks, concealed carry restrictions, bans on dangerous weapons, and gun buyback programs. This paper will argue that place-based preventive interventions such as infrastructure improvements in disadvantaged neighborhoods are a more effective solution to reduce gun violence than the more popular policies that target guns themselves. The paper starts with an analysis of the available empirical data on the four policies mentioned above, concluding that background checks are effective to a small degree, the evidence on concealed carry laws is contradictory and inconclusive, and bans on dangerous weapons and gun buyback programs have been largely ineffective. It then examines harms that arise from these policies that are rarely depicted in the empirical data: a tendency to lead to overcriminalization, disproportionate impacts on racial and ethnic minority individuals, and the spreading of detrimental stigmas towards those with mental illnesses. Next, the central argument in favor of place-based interventions like infrastructure improvements in disadvantaged neighborhoods will be presented. Numerous studies will be referenced to demonstrate that this policy is more effective at reducing overall gun violence than the more popular policies that target guns themselves. Additional advantages of this policy will also be noted, namely that it avoids many of the harms that have historically hindered policies that target guns, it is a cost-effective solution with substantial societal returns on investment, and it is a solution likely to garner bipartisan support given that it avoids challenging the Second Amendment and does not attempt to confiscate guns from legal owners. Finally, this paper will return to the laws that target guns themselves and portray the advantages of regarding them as auxiliary, though still important, policies to reduce gun violence.